If there is one thing we can say for sure, it’s that humans are terrible at analyzing trade-offs. We are terrible at envisioning them before they occur, and we often fail to recognize them after they arrive. This is what Marshall McLuhan meant when he said that self-amputation forbids self-recognition. Yet every time we apply technology to a task or problem, trade-offs occur and unexpected consequences follow.
I remember when people thought social media was just a silly platform for sharing pictures of their dinner. This perspective seems downright naive in hindsight. Yet this pattern repeats itself again and again.
In my previous article on why augmentation is amputation, I introduced a process called ARM (Awareness, Recognition, and Mitigation). This process helps identify and defend the skills you care about. In this article, I’m releasing something to help you understand the trade-offs involved in applying technology to tasks so you can identify negative impacts and account for them.
Even though we know trade-offs happen, we still do nothing about them. There is no attempt at analysis, only adoption. This is why I created The Technology Impact Bowtie.
The Technology Impact Bowtie
Whenever you ask people what skills they need for the future, analyzing trade-offs is noticeably absent. However, I believe analyzing trade-offs is one of the most important skills people can develop in our chaotic, uncertain times. We often rush to push technology as fast as we can, everywhere we can, without ever considering the negative impacts.
During my keynote at Black Hat India, I introduced what I call The Technology Impact Bowtie (TIB) as a way to surface impacts when applying technology to tasks or problems. It makes potential negative impacts visible when other factors often obscure them.
Every time we apply technology to a task or skill area, something is amplified, devalued, and lost, creating impacts. It’s key to surface these impacts so we can account for them.
Often, when applying technology, most of the focus is on what it amplifies and any positive impacts this creates. This amplification obscures other factors, since the amplification is visual and often the reason technology is applied in the first place.
The Technology Impact Bowtie is inspired by the McLuhan Tetrad of Media Effects. However, the McLuhan Tetrad focuses on a specific medium and its overall effects on society, whereas the TIB is a practical approach used when applying technology to a given task or skill. This practicality makes the TIB much more actionable for people and organizations.
Applying the TIB doesn’t have to be some large formal exercise. The TIB is a model, and you can potentially do it entirely in your head, depending on the situation. It can be as simple or as complex as you like.
AI Coding Example
Let’s look at an AI coding example. What follows are just a few simple values for demonstration. For each category, you’d want something a bit more comprehensive to ensure you are capturing the scope of negative effects.
What’s Amplified
The ability to automatically generate code and entire programs, including program testing.
What’s Devalued
Human coding abilities.
What’s Lost
Code comprehension and understanding. Foundational technology skills.
What’s the Impact
Bugs and security issues make it into applications. Failures more difficult to troubleshoot. Technical debt continues to add up.
You can expand on each category of the bowtie by adding more data. This is especially true in the impacts section. For example, losing a skill can create many different impacts that you’d want to account for, which is the whole goal of the process.
Conclusion
As humans are increasingly devalued in technological processes, it’s important that we keep the skills that matter to us. We can’t keep our systems in check if we lose the ability to do so. A big part of retaining these skills is the ability to identify trade-offs. Using the Technology Impact Bowtie and ARM together can be a powerful way to curb the negative impacts of technology adoption, stave off negative consequences, and protect what we care about.
Read it for me, write it for me, think it for me, do it for me. These are the essential commands of the AI era. By thinking we are freeing ourselves, even if we’re only freeing our time, we create more dependence and become further removed from problems. Instead of freedom, we get confinement, locked into doing things because of technique, not excellence, and inevitably dooming us to doing things because we can, not because we should.
We become almost giddy with excitement as we give up our skills and control, content with the illusion of competence, convinced we are the puppet master pulling all the strings, not realizing we’re the ones being pulled, shoved into tiny boxes and constrained in ways we don’t recognize. Novelty and ingenuity are replaced with mechanization and automation, creating conditions where we are far removed from the tasks and problems being solved, leading us to miss the point and build solutions not to the problems themselves, but to problems created by our previous solutions.
This is the world we accelerate into, our destiny. But we must recognize that we are not heading into a solved world. Far from it. We are headed into a world where problems persist, yet we lose the skills necessary to address them directly. Humans are shifting roles from operators to monitors and finally to spectators, creating a world not of abundance but dependence and leaving us vulnerable to a wide range of unintended consequences.
Note: Since people will get the wrong idea, this article isn’t telling people not to use AI. This article is about making purposeful choices, understanding the trade-offs, and deciding what’s best for you and your tasks. Use AI where it benefits you most and employ strategies to protect the skills you care about.
Table of Contents
So What?
As I returned from the annual pilgrimage to Las Vegas for Black Hat and DEF CON, I scribbled my thoughts in a notebook while I waited for my plane’s mechanical issue to be resolved. Needless to say, I didn’t make it home that day.
Fresh on my mind was the apparent nonchalance about the impending death of skills and the changing role of humans in processes. Various people I spoke with throughout the week expressed these views. If you are familiar with my writing, you’ll know this is a topic I spend an inordinate amount of time thinking about. So, before we begin, let’s address the inevitable response: “So what?”
Some may respond that AI and associated tooling let people do more with less, and do it even faster. AI also offers other advantages, like making some processes less error-prone or letting someone with little experience perform a complex task. So, who cares if people lose their skills, or never develop them in the first place? Although this perspective has some substance, it’s hardly universal or evenly distributed across industries and roles, but fair enough. Let’s roll with this.
The thing to consider is that we are not entering a solved world or even a world with a solved industry. This means the problems we face will persist long after we lose our skills. We may gain more tools and more abstraction, but not more insight or knowledge into the problems we need to solve. We are actually getting less. In essence, we create new vulnerabilities and dependencies, but we don’t give them a second thought as we trade them away.
Here are two points to consider about current-state and near-future AI solutions.
AI doesn’t solve all of the problems of any given industry.
AI creates new problems of its own.
Technology is always about trade-offs. Maybe a world with few skills is the world we want, but that’s not a consideration today. Nobody is asking if what we are getting is worth what we are losing. Or even if we can adjust our approach to offset what we are losing, either within the technology or through other methods and controls. Current AI technology is being treated as a total and complete solution without trade-offs, but that isn’t the case. Maybe this is because people think we are building a machine god. However, this thinking leads us to ignore the unintended consequences looming on the horizon.
This article isn’t meant to propose a universal solution to the issues emerging from trade-offs. In many cases, especially when transforming entire industries, there isn’t much we can do. In a way, it reminds me of Jacques Ellul writing an entire book on what he called “technique.” His book is filled with observations of decline and negative impacts on humans but not a single solution. He presented the information to surface the issues, making them visible to readers. Individuals were left to ponder and potentially mitigate how/if they pleased.
My hope is that at least some people will become more sensitive to what they may be losing so they can shore up gaps, either in their own knowledge or in the processes they employ. We as individuals need to protect what we care about, because other people won’t.
The Changing Role of the Human
What’s the human role in our newly developed technological systems? We’ve become so caught up in using tools that we become blind to their true impacts.
Instead of being operators, hands-on with the environment and problems we are trying to solve, we’re becoming monitors, hands-off, happy to observe, setting the process in motion but taking no part in it. Jacques Ellul noticed this shift back in the 1950s, and it’s gotten far worse since then.
This means that man participates less and less actively in technical creation, which, by the automatic combination of prior elements, becomes a kind of fate. Man is reduced to the level of a catalyst. Better still, he resembles a slug inserted into a slot machine: he starts the operation without participating in it. -Jacques Ellul, The Technological Society (1954)
Modern slot machines are a great example because they often give us the impression of winning even as we lose. In her excellent article on “dark flow,” Rachel Thomas said this:
On a traditional slot machine, you either win or lose. In contrast, multiline slot machines have 20 rows going at once and reward partial “credits” that create a false sense of winning even as you lose. For example, you can gamble 20 cents and receive a 15 cent “credit”. This is actually a 5 cent loss, yet the slot machine plays celebratory noises that trigger a positive dopamine reaction. -Rachel Thomas
We certainly don’t see ourselves as merely slugs in a machine. We see ourselves as winners, even as we lose, and don’t recognize the difference between AI doing something and us doing something. We see it as one and the same. However, even though AI is a tool, it’s also our competition, stealing opportunities and experience and robbing us of knowledge and understanding.
These issues are not new. In the “Monitoring” section of her 1983 paper called Ironies of Automation, Lisanne Bainbridge makes the following observation about the human capability to take over from an automated system:
“One complexity which it does raise of course is that the supervisor too will not be able to take-over if he has not been reviewing his relevant knowledge, or practising a crucial manual skill.” Lisanne Bainbridge, Ironies of Automation (1983)
Granted, it’s not always extreme, and we may not care about some skills. Fair enough. However, we aren’t recognizing the condition at all today and making conscious decisions about which skills to protect and which we are comfortable losing. We are setting the stage for the emergence of unintended consequences, including the death of skills and the persistence of problems.
The Death of Skills
So, we are confronted with a core question:
What does the death of skills and the changing role of humans mean as we face an unsolved world?
I’ve been warning about what I call cognitive atrophy, or what some call cognitive surrender, for years now. I’ve mapped out what I call the personas of personal AI. These are the personas users want AI to embody for them as they over-rely on the technology. I’ve also called out some impacts, which I refer to as the four D’s of personal AI risk. These are just a taste, but augmentation with technology has many consequences people don’t recognize.
Augmentation is Amputation
Marshall McLuhan observed that every augmentation is also an amputation, one that forbids self-recognition. That lack of self-recognition is why we often don’t notice the negative impacts of augmenting ourselves with technology. Although we will eventually notice muscle atrophy in our legs when we augment them with something like a robotic exoskeleton, atrophy in cognitive tasks can be much harder to confront.
Self-amputation forbids self-recognition. -Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media (1964)
This lack of self-recognition means we won’t even recognize the condition as skills atrophy and wither.
The number of people who seem perfectly fine being replaced, outsourcing all of their tasks and reducing their relevance, is puzzling. As Marcus Hutchins recently put it, “Being promoted to the world’s saddest project manager.”
I believe people aren’t concerned for several reasons, one of which is that playing with tech can be fun. But I think this mostly comes from the impression of being an all-powerful puppet master, completely in control, commanding a fleet of agents doing your bidding. But that’s not how it works in practice.
Humans evolved to be cognitively lazy and, like water, we take the path of least resistance. The call of cognitive offloading is too powerful, and the allure of an oracle is too enticing for many to resist.
Take the case of Josh Autenrieth. In 2020, an explosion at Watson Grinding triggered a lawsuit that included the company 3M. 3M engaged Autenrieth, who works for Nighthawk Engineering, to prepare an expert report. When one of the plaintiff’s attorneys noticed that the report appeared to have been generated by ChatGPT, the attorney requested all the prompts, a precedent that will no doubt be utilized far more in the future.
The details are egregious, and the full story, detailed by 404 Media, can be read here. Let’s just say this wasn’t someone using ChatGPT to write a report for them. Autenrieth also used ChatGPT to do the analysis and thinking for him, basically doing the job he was hired to do. Let’s keep in mind that he’s supposed to be an expert, but the 404 Media article had examples like this:
Although it’s easy to roll your eyes and call this an exception, it’s not the exception people think it is. We are creating an entire society of Autenrieths. They are out there, doing work every day. Not at some distant point on the horizon, but today. The only difference is they don’t have a court of law to scrutinize their work product. They may be in different industries with different stakes, but they are out there nonetheless.
We all know someone, or work with someone, who was barely competent at their job in the first place, but now, with ChatGPT, Copilot, or whatever, they project themselves as rock stars, flexing the epitome of competence but creating a slop-filled swamp, leaving more competent people to take on the role of slop janitor.
As a critic, I find the stories people tell me both comical and terrifying. For example, the developers who are told that they care too much and that their job isn’t to write code anymore, but to be QA. Meanwhile, their co-workers hurriedly push code into production without understanding it. Others don’t realize their builds are failing and struggle with foundational technologies like Terraform. Today’s foundational skills will confound tomorrow’s workers.
The sad part is that this is exactly the situation AI companies want. A society of Autenrieths with degraded skills and high tool dependence. Ah, I can smell the utopia now.
Losing skills has a blast radius we often don’t recognize. Most people don’t give using GPS a second thought compared with using maps or landmarks, but it’s been linked to a loss of spatial memory. What else might we be giving up that we don’t realize until it’s too late?
Trading Strong Skills for Weak Skills
People who lose skills can struggle to recognize the loss. This is especially true when a role or industry has already shifted, and new people enter the workforce. You are unlikely to identify missing skills you never developed. Even worse, when shown these foundational skills, newcomers to a field may find practicing them painful.
However, during the shift, this lack of identification is further obscured when exchanging strong skills for weak ones, because weak skills can masquerade as strong skills. Basically, the person with the traded skills still feels like they are accomplishing the same tasks, even though they’re not exercising the same skills. In many cases, this may even be true, but only up to a point.
For example, monitoring a dashboard or configuring a UI is a weak skill because it completely obscures the underlying activities and their complexity. It’s both a bug and a feature. In many cases, the user knows there’s a configuration option or checkbox, but has no idea what actually happens when they select it. This is what I mean when I say we are transitioning to being more “hands-off” with processes.
Imagine an analyst who used to reverse engineer malware to understand how it works, now merely uploading it to an AI tool and getting a high-level report. Or a penetration tester who previously used a variety of techniques and tools to identify weaknesses in a system, now merely pointing an AI-powered scanner at an environment and reading the results.
We are replacing discovery through exploration and the direct application of skills and knowledge with automated responses curated through dashboards and user interfaces. This is further fueled by people’s preference for being told things rather than discovering them, which also negatively impacts satisfaction. Of course, only one of these scenarios allows technical knowledge to grow and new discoveries to emerge.
“One result of skill is that the operator knows he can take-over adequately if required. Otherwise the job is one of the worst types, it is very boring but very responsible, yet there is no opportunity to aquire or maintain the qualities required to handle the responsibility.” -Lisanne Bainbridge, Ironies of Automation (1983)
In many ways, this aligns with our innate human need for shortcuts and an organization’s desire for optimization. We’d rather be told answers than discover them. But nobody thinks about the current situation this way. This skill trading is a byproduct of a role change or a new tool that reshapes the landscape, so it can “feel” as though we’ve gained something even though we’ve lost it.
Death of Future Skills
Humans aren’t being replaced en masse by AI in the workforce yet, although they are being replaced by high hopes. Actually, this isn’t entirely true. AI is affecting some industries more than others, mainly jobs in media and arts. However, where AI is deployed and how it’s used can have a cascading effect.
AI can become a self-fulfilling prophecy for the extinction of skills, creating conditions for skill degradation in the present and guaranteeing their extinction in the future. This happens as junior roles are eliminated, change completely, or lose chances to flex real skills. This condition isn’t obvious or a concern for a CEO focused on quarterly numbers, but it should matter to us and society at large. A lack of skills creates vulnerabilities.
There is some concern that the present generation of automated systems, which are monitored by former manual operators, are riding on their skills, which later generations of operators cannot be expected to have. -Lisanne Bainbridge, Ironies of Automation (1983)
Fragility
Our technologically advanced world seems all-powerful, as though we can accomplish anything, but this perception masks a dark truth. Our modern, advanced world is incredibly fragile. We see it every time a natural disaster, power outage, war, or other unexpected event occurs. Although unexpected events on this scale seem rare, they are far more common in everyday life and business.
When people lose or fail to develop skills, the world becomes even more fragile because dependency skyrockets. Small issues can balloon into major problems. People fail to understand not only how the systems they interact with work, but also how the whole world works. We are left with a world where technology-created problems can only be solved by piling on even more technology because we lack insight into the true nature of problems. Human ingenuity is no longer a factor because we’re too far removed.
AI Is Not Just Any Tool
Part of the nonchalance about AI stems from the perception that AI is just a tool like any other. Although I agree that (today) AI is just a tool, it’s not just any tool. It’s a cognitive tool that can plan and take action. A tool that abstracts us from the problems we are trying to solve, adding complexity in the process. Only the complexity is completely obscured behind a simple-looking response.
Many now believe what we are going through is like other technological revolutions, and that we’ll just adapt to this new way of doing things. One example is the shift from programming in assembly language to a higher-level language like C or Python, and now we are programming in “natural language,” but this isn’t remotely the same.
With a high-level programming language, you’re still confronted with a representation of the problem space. You subsequently need to perform actions such as setting and reading variables, performing iterations, and debugging and troubleshooting. What changes is syntax. Sure, the developer becomes abstracted from opcodes, registers, and other platform specifics, but the shape of the problem remains.
Sure, the generated code can still be reviewed and debugged by a human. This is true. But those skills degrade when you don’t write code manually at least some of the time. The human simply becomes a meat sack button pusher, approving every change and often not realizing something isn’t working as expected.
In addition, when performing the task yourself, you’re forced to reason about the situation and problems you face. There’s less cognitive laziness in writing code by hand. Well, for those who don’t simply copy/paste everything from Stack Overflow anyway. In many cases, you need to reason about what you are doing and why. This is not the case with AI.
Developers are now told their job isn’t to write and understand code or to understand architecture, but to push more code. This is like telling a carpenter their job isn’t to understand construction or architectural plans, but to use more lumber. The negative consequences of both scenarios should be obvious.
As I mentioned, AI use doesn’t represent a problem space. It’s more like an amorphous blob giving no indication of shape or form. Requests are issued, output is spit out, and decisions are made. We are no longer hands-on with problems. We are miles away munching on a cheeseburger, waiting for a notification of a result.
Each AI advancement is dehumanizing and removes agency. This isn’t always bad. For example, we may decide that self-driving cars are preferable to human-driven cars, so we give up some agency and the human aspects of driving. But we should recognize that this dehumanization and removal of agency happens to whatever activity AI is applied to.
Losing the shape and form of problems creates many unintended consequences. In the self-driving car example, humans are asked to take control in the most challenging of situations. The very situations they are now unprepared for due to the dehumanization of driving.
Ultimately, we lose our understanding of both the domain the problem exists in and our ability to recognize true problems. The human is abstracted from both, further distancing us from the problems we are trying to solve.
Problem Proximity
Proximity to a problem is essential to understanding it. Being close and understanding the mechanics involved is essential for creating solutions. A layperson isn’t going to point ChatGPT at cancer and command it to provide a cure. This may seem like a silly example, but it is exactly how many people try to solve problems with AI today.
Removing yourself from a problem obscures all the surrounding complexity. It’s one of the reasons people thought the vulnpocalypse would happen. With AI identifying so many vulnerabilities, how could it not? But real-world attacks and scenarios require far more than vulnerabilities, and attackers have monetary constraints too.
Cybersecurity vendors are now working to completely remove analysts from the security operations center (SOC) and replace them with AI agents. What happens when attackers keep their skills but defenders either lose theirs or their jobs disappear completely? That’s not a good scenario. Companies will be constantly surprised by successful attacks.
What happens when attackers keep their skills but defenders either lose theirs or their jobs disappear completely?
Sometimes people are too close to problems, and a bit of distance helps them find solutions. This is true. However, in this scenario, people still need the perspective gained from being close to the problem in the first place.
We are moving to a distance-only future. We will no longer have close proximity to techniques and problems. We are approaching the world as though we already have AGI and are headed for a life of leisure, but we doom ourselves to a future of constant problems and unknowns.
Domain Expertise
Domain expertise requires depth and experience, two things that run counter to what AI promotes. Thankfully, we still have a wealth of domain expertise today. However, this domain expertise creates a blind spot when it comes to AI.
When a domain expert experiments with AI, they tend to overlook the issues. They can spot the problems and make corrections. They end up “filling in the blanks,” both physically and mentally. This is partly how smart people can get captured by AI hype.
Although AI seems to reward domain expertise today, it also atrophies it, as we have seen in the previous sections. As people are further abstracted away from performing direct tasks, domain expertise weakens.
Technique
We are searching for the one best way, the ultimate optimization, the final optimization, if you will. Previously, I mentioned Jacques Ellul and his concept of “technique.” In the foreword section of The Technological Society, Robert K. Merton summarized Ellul’s term “technique” as “Far more than machine technology. Technique refers to any complex of standardized means for attaining a predetermined result.”
AI represents the ultimate attempt at technique. It’s the attempt to build a universal technique machine, to step aside, and let the machine continue the path itself, with humans no longer even catalysts but passive observers, reduced to cheering fans in front of television screens. This represents the ultimate transformation of the human role in processes: from operator to monitor to spectator. Proponents believe that this technique will conquer space and time. It’s easy to lose sight of the fact that this is all purely speculative.
We forget that the world is complex, often confounding our assumptions, and the implementation of “technique” has an odd way of opening us up to new attacks and failures. These are not unlike the Air France flight 447 incident, in which deskilled pilots couldn’t manually fly the plane after the autopilot disengaged and an unexpected situation arose.
ARM Yourself
All of these conditions beg the question: what can we do? In many cases, individuals can’t do much to drive broader change, especially when industry roles are changing, or your boss tells you your job is simply to commit more code. Society and industries seem to accept these changes as destiny. After all, AI and related AI-powered tooling are a form of “technique,” as Ellul elucidated. Still, that doesn’t mean we are completely helpless.
As individuals, we should enact mitigations to protect what we care about. What we care about shouldn’t be limited to applied skills or technical applications. We should also consider scenarios involving human communication and interaction, given their dehumanizing effects.
Look for conditions where a tool performs the analysis or “thinking” for you, performs a critical skill necessary for your job, or even communicates with a human on your behalf. These are ripe areas for protection.
To support this analysis, I suggest a three-step process I call ARM.
Awareness
Recognition
Mitigation
The first step is simply to be aware that conditions of cognitive degradation and decay exist. Hopefully, my work and the work of others help with this.
Second, recognize when these conditions show up in your daily life. This isn’t as easy as it seems. Remember McLuhan’s quote about self-augmentation forbidding self-recognition. This requires purposeful analysis. Periodically perform a skills audit to examine your tasks and how you accomplish them. Identify conditions that may be affecting the skills you care about.
To support the recognition step, you can also build a habit of occasionally forming a hypothesis and then checking your work against AI output. Basically, you perform the task, then have the AI perform it. If the outputs match, that’s a positive sign that you maintain at least some of the core skills you’re trying to protect. If they don’t, then you need to implement some mitigations.
Finally, implement mitigations to protect the skill or scenario. This step can also be difficult because humans are cognitively lazy, and once something feels “optimized,” it’s hard to go back. Mitigation doesn’t necessarily mean abstinence. However, you may choose to have a no-AI rule for specific activities or communication methods.
Choose an approach that you feel protects what you care about. For example, you can exercise some tool-free practice days to keep your skills sharp. Or you could implement a human first-pass rule and only add AI after you’ve done a first pass yourself. Use the strategy that works for you.
By now you are probably thinking, “Wow, that seems like a lot of work.” It certainly can be. That’s why you are only implementing these strategies for skills you care about protecting. These strategies can also be critical for workers new to a job or industry, allowing them to practice foundational skills before AI tooling abstracts them away. Something to think about whether you are the new employee or a people manager.
Let me throw out a few examples.
Examples
I don’t use AI to write anything for me. Writing is thinking. I painstakingly write every word either by putting pen to paper or in an editor like Ulysses. This is because I’ve seen how it sharpens my thinking and lets new insights emerge. Insights that wouldn’t have come about otherwise.
The response may be, “But isn’t that time-consuming?” Yes! It absolutely is, and that’s the point. As for the inevitable question about time, it’s simple. Don’t spend time on things you don’t care about. Life is too short.
In another example, maybe you have a repetitive task, like searching through a group of files for certain conditions and extracting them. In many cases, this isn’t a skill you want to protect, and you’re happy handing it off to a tool and making better use of your time.
Finally, what about reporting? On the surface, reporting may seem similar to the file search case, but it really depends. You want to ensure the analysis and insights are coming from you and your expertise. Don’t pull an Autenrieth. If the tool is simply taking care of the formatting and other miscellaneous wrapper content and the analysis and insights are yours, then this may be fine. Obviously, as long as you check the work product.
However, if additional insights emerge while you write the report yourself, you may want to keep the task rather than outsource it. It depends on what the report is for, who will consume it, and how valuable it is to you.
It Doesn’t Have To Be
The sad part is that systems don’t have to be designed like this, to devalue the human and degrade their skills. It’s possible to design systems that augment and strengthen the human involved in the process. And yes, using AI. It’s just that no one has the appetite to address this. The whole emphasis of AI investment is on removing humans from various processes completely.
However, if we look closer, the benefit is obvious. The approach leaves room for new discoveries, new innovation, and the opportunity to be far more robust when unexpected situations arise, creating a best-of-both-worlds scenario. But I wouldn’t hold my breath that this will happen on purpose.
You can also use AI tools without experiencing cognitive degradation. People do it every day. However, this isn’t how most people use the AI tools at their disposal. They may not have gone full Autenrieth yet, but they are on the path. In the immortal words of the great American philosopher Ice Cube, “You better check yo self before you wreck yo self.”
Conclusion
In a recent article, Minh-Hoang Nguyen argues that a new kind of brain rot is “intellectual cowardice.” This is useful framing. We’ve gotten away from using language like this. We need to elevate the concept of “honorable” activities and call out the dishonorable or cowardly ones. This framing mirrors my conversations. I often describe activities as “honorable” or “dishonorable.” For example, spending twelve hours a day on social media and ignoring your family is not an honorable activity. We should be elevating more honorable activities.
People often talk about the utopian freedom that AI can bring, but in many cases they describe a life of dependence and confinement. We are offered the illusion of choice when the path has already been chosen, and we remain vulnerable to every unknown thrown across our path. Ellul was right: technique is coming for us all. We must protect what we care about, because nobody else will.
Note About McLuhan and Amputation
Some who have never read Understanding Media may nitpick that McLuhan never actually uttered the words “every augmentation is an amputation.” Although this is true, it’s also certainly what he meant. McLuhan mentions “amputation” or “amputated” seventeen times alone in his chapter called “The Gadget Lover.” Below is the closest line to this:
Any invention or technology is an extension or self-amputation of our physical bodies, and such extension also demands new ratios or new equilibriums among the other organs and extensions of the body. -Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media (1964)
So, yes. Although he never said the exact phrase, anyone who has spent time reading Understanding Media knows that’s certainly what he meant.
You’ve heard these two phrases uttered thousands of times. They creep into every conversation about AI and work, being mindlessly parroted as people nod in involuntary agreement. Two phrases that seem incredibly simple yet are loaded with a potential world of problems. They are:
AI won’t replace people. People using AI will replace those who don’t.
And.
Just use AI for everything.
These two phrases, the first a statement of truth and the second a piece of advice, shouldn’t be mindlessly heeded and require a closer look. The advice dispensed in these statements is not only untrue but also bad for you.
No Malicious Intent
To start, I don’t think most people using these phrases are malicious or deliberately misleading. It’s quite the opposite. I think they genuinely want to help people and have good intentions. After all, I often hear these phrases from well-meaning people, not from overhyping tech bros. Tech bros feel that a conversation around these two statements is beneath them, and anyone considering them is too stupid to exist in the future of work anyway.
The real problem is that nobody has spent much time reflecting on the meaning of these phrases or considering their implications in the grand scheme of things.
The Laziest Statement In AI
Let’s begin with the laziest statement in AI.
AI won’t replace people. People using AI will replace those who don’t.
There is a mental trick to the phrase that makes it sticky. When people repeat the phrase, it’s a way of letting others know that they are fine with technology. They are up to date and hip with the hype. This is one of the reasons for the phrase’s popularity. However, most using this phrase are merely parroting others. They haven’t given it much thought. It seems logical enough, so uttering the phrase in a conversation is almost an involuntary response, but this statement falls apart under the slightest scrutiny.
The first part of the phrase invokes a sigh of relief. With the current level of AI hype, many people are concerned about being replaced. This first part puts people at ease, but that ease is temporary.
The second part of the phrase issues a call to action with an implied sense of urgency, warning people that they had better get on board. The AI train is leaving the station, and you don’t want to be left behind.
Never mind the fact that neither the first nor the second part of the statement is true.
AI won’t replace people.
Although many of the AI layoff announcements are nothing but AI washing, if they are to be believed, then AI is absolutely replacing people. But even setting this reality aside, CEOs have made it clear they want to replace you. The moment an AI tool is mediocre enough to do your job, it’s done, done, doneski. They are like rabid dogs roaming the corporate directory in search of employees to maul.
In fact, people are being fired preemptively because of AI. Look at the recent layoffs of Oracle and Meta for examples of these. People are losing their jobs not because AI can do their jobs, but because of the mere idea of AI.
You don’t think investors are dumping truckloads of money into AI because it’s a productivity booster, do you? No, replacing people is absolutely the goal. As a matter of fact, replacing people may be the only viable path given the amount of investment. In the immortal words of Aldous Huxley, nothing short of everything will really do.
Everywhere possible, organizations have shoved generative AI into everything in an attempt to replace people, from newsrooms to Human Resources and everywhere in between. AI companies are even trying to replace your friends and loved ones. Yes, AI will absolutely replace people whenever capabilities allow. However, we aren’t there yet.
The thing workers have going for them is that today’s generative AI isn’t capable of replacing large swaths of the workforce. It’s much more likely that additional innovation will be required for that to happen.
People using AI will replace those who don’t
But what about the second part of the statement? People who use AI will replace those who don’t. This requires some deeper analysis.
To begin with, there’s a subtle, nefarious aspect to the second sentence in this phrase. It’s an attempt to make AI part of your identity. This is worse than it seems. Sorry, I know you were good at your job, but your skills have now been devalued. If you don’t slop, you’re gonna have to stop… working here.
But surely, tools tied to identities are common. What about something like a hammer to a carpenter? This is true, but the hammer doesn’t define the carpenter. A hammer is also one tool among many in the carpenter’s toolkit. It’s not like the carpenter brings the hammer to the dinner table to pass the mashed potatoes. A carpenter also doesn’t use the hammer as a confessional, a companion, or a lover. No, a carpenter has an identity without the hammer.
Even for something as specific as a pole vaulter, where “pole” is literally in the person’s title, the pole doesn’t generalize across tasks. Therefore, it’s only useful in one very narrow activity. The pole isn’t a tool for daily decision-making. You can’t cognitively offload to the pole.
What does all of this say about you? That your value lies in AI usage, not in your actual skills and capabilities. That you, as an employee, are no better than any other employee using AI. There’s no differentiation. And no, stating that you prompt better than someone else isn’t the differentiator people think it is.
If AI is doing everything, then what are you doing? No doubt people imagine themselves as the all-powerful puppet master pulling the strings, but the reality may very well be the opposite: the user is the one getting their strings pulled as they are transformed into a digital janitor. Cleanup in cubicle 5.
Companies themselves often don’t care. They are looking for someone to fill a position. The reality is that you and AI are no different than someone else with AI. In this situation, AI becomes an equalizer, but in the worst way.
In this situation, AI becomes an equalizer, but in the worst way.
Now, there are certainly exceptions and exceptional people. Companies may be hiring for an AI developer role. There may be other roles where AI usage aligns more with job tasks, too. Keep in mind, these are exceptions, and we are talking about rules. Even in these exceptional cases, people need to consider differentiation outside of AI.
How will you differentiate in the current environment? What’s your story? What are your passions? What do you bring to the table that isn’t AI? How do you apply your skills and expertise to the job to differentiate yourself from the AI-dependent? This probably requires a whole post of its own.
There’s more to say here, but that involves looking at our next piece of advice.
Use AI For Everything?
And now, everybody’s favorite phrase.
Just use AI for everything.
That’s right. Don’t be selective. Don’t differentiate tasks. Damn the torpedos it’s full slop ahead. There are so many issues with this statement that it’s hard to choose a place to begin. But let me start by saying the phrase “Just use AI for everything” and “People using AI will replace people who don’t” are two sides of the same coin.
I’m not claiming that today’s generative AI doesn’t have its uses. It certainly does, but it’s a tool one can utilize for tasks. So, use it for everything? Seriously? Should we let ChatGPT run air traffic control? Should we replace our loved ones with AI? Should we use AI to write a sympathy email? The list goes on and on, and the answer to all of these should be no. Unfortunately, it looks like that’s exactly what we are getting in the air traffic control use case. This is absolutely insane, since it can’t even manage inventory at a Starbucks. The ATC scenario is my go-to for highlighting idiotic use cases, so I guess I need to find another one.
There are three immediate reasons to question using AI for everything: it devalues the activity, degrades your skills, and dehumanizes you and others. For a deeper dive, see my Four Ds of Personal AI Risk article, where I also cover disconnection.
Given the potential negative consequences, we should be selective in our use of AI for tasks and processes, using it where it is most appropriate and not for everything. After all, there may be tradeoffs we are willing to accept. Fair enough, but often these tradeoffs are made without a single thought.
Devaluation
Every time AI is added to a task, the value of that task lowers. For example, let’s look at sentiment analysis. Let’s say we have a human analyzing a host of reviews of a company’s products. The human determines whether the sentiment is positive or negative and forwards feedback to product teams.
AI has been capable of performing sentiment analysis for quite some time. The value of having a human do this decreases, even in conditions where the human is better, for example, in sensing sarcasm. If an algorithm only sends negative feedback to the product team, it may miss valuable insights in positive reviews as well. This is a tradeoff and one a company may happily make.
This isn’t universally a bad thing. Sometimes, this is beneficial. Maybe there’s a process in which, every time a condition is met, a check is put in a box inside a document. It may seem hard to argue that we need to add more value to this process. Yes, we are making a bunch of assumptions about the task, error rates, and a host of other factors, but the point still holds.
Now, let’s say we automate this checking of the box. The process will continue the same way until the heat death of the universe. Maybe this is perfectly okay. Fair enough. However, when a human performs the task (or a human is at least in the loop), questions may continue to surface as the business itself changes. Does the activity make sense? Maybe the activity itself provides no value. Maybe the activity can be enriched to provide even more value. All of this is lost once the human is removed from the equation.
It may be argued that other people in the chain could also come to these conclusions, yes, that is true, but often these insights come from people closest to the task, the very ones that have been removed with automation. It’s this insight that spells bad news for companies that want to get rid of people and replace them with AI.
There’s also the case where people in the chain create slop and send it on to their coworkers to fix a condition dubbed workslop. This actually creates more work for humans, despite using AI. This only gives the appearance of productivity, but it moves tasks around like a shell game.
Of course, all of this is moot when CEOs and other executives demand that their employees use AI. When this happens, out of fear and a need to demonstrate they are using AI, people will try to use AI for everything, further accelerating the creation of workslop.
Here’s the CEO of Box with a bit of insight.
He’s right, this distance is something CEOs and other executives don’t realize exists. In other cases, they spend far too much time reading nonsense news articles and half-baked analyst reports, thinking they are being left behind. Most CEOs don’t have the time (or won’t make time) for meaningful AI use. They play around, run a few experiments, and think they need far fewer employees. Of course, even more usage and experimentation could also fuel more delusions.
When executives demand that their employees maximize their use of AI, it further devalues what people do on a daily basis. Then again, not respecting your employees has become a bit of a theme lately.
Degradation
When it comes to degradation, there are two types of degradation we are concerned with. The degradation of the task or process being performed and the degradation of our own cognitive abilities.
Process Degradation
Let’s start with a question. Does adding AI to a task make it better or worse? I know, what is the definition of “better” in this context? Let’s say, for the sake of our conversation, that better refers to quality.
In a monumental number of cases, there’s absolutely no attempt to answer this question. It’s just that if AI can do it, people apply AI to it. It’s the Jeff Goldblum Jurassic Park meme approach to applying AI. Back in 2023, I wrote a whole post covering this degradation in applications.
In many cases, AI makes things worse or, at the very least, has no impact. In the cases where it’s made things worse, the output is acceptable enough for the task. An example of this degradation would be replacing a product’s search feature with an AI-powered one, which can lead to failures in simple pattern matching. Which, I don’t know, seems to be the entire purpose of the search feature. I mean, have you tried to use the search functionality on X lately?
I’ve said this many times over the past few years, but in an attempt to make hard things easy, many have made easy things hard. Welcome to the brave new world of degraded performance.
In an attempt to make hard things easy, many have made easy things hard.
Once AI appears to work, companies high-five and move on with life. If you don’t believe me, AI is being shoved into every conceivable crevice of our existence. Where has it made things meaningfully better? The AI phone representative, the AI features in applications, the AI operating system, and the list goes on and on. None of which we asked for and all of which we got.
I don’t mean to make this sound like there aren’t successful AI use cases. These certainly exist, and you can find them in places like software engineering or even cybersecurity. However, even in these successful use cases, the tradeoffs are rarely addressed. Only recently have people begun to talk about things like technical debt and cost.
There are certainly other cases where AI makes a meaningful positive impact. These may be due to volume, complexity, or other factors that humans struggle with. These are good candidates for AI applications. Imagine having to manually review 10,000 product reviews a day. Where companies run into issues is that they don’t have a way to measure the success of their experiments with any meaningful metric other than whether it appears to work.
Cognitive Degradation (Cognitive Atrophy)
AI is a tool that augments human tasks and activities through outsourcing. What sets AI apart from other, more common tools is that it is a generalized cognitive tool. Rather than augmenting a part of our body for focused tasks, as a hammer does, it augments our cognitive processes across a wide range of tasks. The benefit is also a tremendous detriment.
I’ve discussed cognitive offloading and cognitive atrophy many times throughout the years. It’s one of my biggest AI concerns. A few examples can be found here, here, and here.
The best way to think about AI is that it’s a competitive technology, and every time we use it, we are also competing with it. This isn’t as negative as it sounds. As humans, we collaborate with people we may be competing with, but we bring a different mindset to this activity under such circumstances. However, this is not the same mindset we bring to using an AI tool. We can claim it’s all us, without doing the work.
The best way to think about AI is that it’s a competitive technology, and every time we use it, we are also competing with it.
At best, AI rounds off the corners of human skills, and at worst, it atrophies them to the point of uselessness. As Nicolas Carr said in his book The Shallows, the brighter the software, the dimmer the user.
When I first started talking about the cognitive impacts of AI, it was a pretty lonely position. Now it seems you can’t go a couple of days without these issues being highlighted. A few examples from the past few months can be seen here, here, here, and here. There’s plenty more.
The challenge manifests when you try to add interventions to protect your cognitive capabilities and skills. Once the friction is removed, it all seems like additional work. And it is. However, if you want to continue using AI tools while protecting yourself, you will need to do additional work.
You don’t become a better coder by not coding or a better writer by not writing. Not doing makes you worse at these things, which certainly isn’t a benefit in the job market.
This needs to be tweaked and, in some cases, inverted. LLMs impress the non-writers who want to write, the non-coders who want to code, the researchers who simply want to boost their publication count, and the lawyers who’d rather be drinking.
In the end, using AI for creative tasks impresses only the people who use it, and those are people with no particular taste or talent.
Dehumanization
The use of AI dehumanizes you and others. It does this almost by its very nature of use, removing humans from the process. It numbs your senses to other people’s conditions and treats them more like apps than humans. I wrote about this condition and the dehumanization that comes from simulating emotions with AI back in early 2023.
To summarize, let’s take the example of a sympathy card. I’d take a poorly worded, human-written card over a perfectly worded AI-written card any day. It really is the thought that counts. This is something that every human innately understands. In the previous post, I used the example of a sympathy email on the loss of a child. Heavy.
The point is that the activity isn’t supposed to be comfortable, and its true value comes from the discomfort. While writing, we are forced to reflect on the situation, put ourselves in the person’s shoes, and connect with our feelings and our fellow humans. This makes us better people, far more appreciative of what we have and less likely to take things for granted. None of that happens when AI is used.
AI, in many cases, carries the potential to turn us into automatons performing tasks devoid of emotion. We shouldn’t allow ourselves to be turned into machines.
I mean, if we are using AI for everything, why not use AI to interview people for jobs? Hopefully, it is clear that this is fairly dystopian. Here’s a video of a guy doing a mock interview with an AI tool. Some people consider this progress and on the path to utopia, but I consider it the shitularity.
Conclusion
Lazy thinking dressed up as wisdom is the currency of our era. No time for reflection, only for reaction. As we’ve seen, the two phrases we examined aren’t harmless. Your hard-won expertise and domain experience remain valuable, but are absolutely things you can lose if not properly exercised.
None of this means rejecting the use of AI outright. It means being selective in your usage and application. The problem is that many aren’t considering the trade-offs. This needs to change. The next few years will bring challenges to both our humanity and our dignity. Lean into your strengths, find your differentiators, and defend your humanity.
It seems AI is becoming one of the most volatile and expensive dependencies in modern systems, and most organizations aren’t prepared for what comes next. I recently wrote an article for Modern CISO on AI cost volatility, offering observations and recommendations to mitigate this risk.
Token Ransom and High Cost
For years, we’ve been told to prepare for the cost of intelligence to crash to zero.
The narrative pushed in this tweet by Logan Kilpatrick is something I’ve called out in the past for its sheer ridiculousness. But many are seeing the light in the last few weeks. Everywhere you turn, AI services are getting more expensive. Every day, new providers are making announcements. One example below is from GitHub Copilot’s new pricing.
Even the all-you-can-eat AI buffet for $20 a month was always a myth. This was part of a larger narrative pushed by influencers, futurists, and AI leaders, but this narrative always made dollars and no sense.
What happens when you deploy solutions using these cutting-edge foundation models into production environments? You may end up with a dependency where you have a choice. Pay more or have the solution stop working. In the article, I refer to this as a token ransom.
Think of this as a token ransom. It’s scary to consider how the ransomware of the future may actually be an inflated token cost.
If companies aren’t prepared for these scenarios, they carry significant operational risk. In the article, I break down the issues with more examples and provide recommendations on how to start addressing them.
You can read the full write-up for Modern CISO here. Although framed toward security leaders, the advice is applicable beyond the cybersecurity space.
One interesting outcome of these price increases is that companies are very concerned. It seems no amount of security and reliability issues dissuaded these companies from chucking AI into everything, but the skyrocketing cost of AI may. I’ve heard far more grumblings about cost than security issues. Only time will tell.
Since this site focuses on risks and trade-offs rather than shiny, utopian use cases, there is some confusion about my thoughts on AI. Be it the AI of the present or the AI of the future. With this post, I stake out my position on AI and its advancement so I don’t have to keep restating it. Also, it’s good to write down your beliefs and confront yourself with them. Sometimes what you think you believe isn’t what you actually believe. Maybe I’m a secret AI bro after all. Utopia, here we come!
AI acceleration has become a cult or religion, and offering any criticism of its advancement is taken as a personal attack. In many ways, if you swapped out AI for cryptocurrency, the theme would revive a familiar tone.
Even with this post, I’ll undoubtedly be pegged as an AI hater because I don’t have pictures of myself lying prostrate in front of a pile of GPUs. Any time you shed light on hype or bullshit, people are willing to label you a hater. That’s the easiest thing for them to do, and it takes no mental effort and requires no skill. With that said, here we go.
On AI Advancement Summary
I’ve been using this image in my conference presentations since 2023. The focus of my talks is on risk, which means talking about problems and challenges most of the time rather than amazing use cases. I wanted to show the audience that I don’t hate the technology.
The problem with being in the middle is that both sides typically frame you as an extremist. You don’t hate the technology enough for one side or love it enough for the other. Realities on the ground typically hover somewhere in the middle between extreme claims. This isn’t rocket science.
For those who honestly don’t care about the rest of this post and made it this far, here’s a quick summary:
I’m not a skeptic, I’m a critic
Yes, I think today’s AI can be useful
Yes, there are some use cases that I’m hopeful for
No, I don’t think today’s AI is AGI
Yes, I think AGI is possible
No, I don’t think LLMs will lead to AGI
I think even AGI will have vulnerabilities
I’m not so sure about the concept of ASI or the intelligence explosion
I’m Not a Skeptic, I’m a Critic
In the current era, I’ve seen people frame themselves as skeptics either of technology or of AI. This is not how I frame myself. I consider myself a critic, not a skeptic. I’ve joked that I’m a hype critic. Throughout my career, I’ve offered criticism of the state on cybersecurity, emerging technologies, and, especially, product manufacturers and their claims.
I believe that technology does need a better class of criticism. The tech press, in large part, has abdicated its responsibility, choosing instead to mindlessly parrot opinions from tech leaders. The entire world has been a gigantic sycophantic feedback loop. This is something I’ve called out many times myself and something that Karl Bode calls “CEO Said A Thing!” Journalism.
Most people criticizing the state of technology are insufferable. The few valuable points they present are wrapped in politics, bullshit, and, in some cases, conspiracy theories. Their goals aren’t to effect change but to pander to their audience. The very people who need to hear these points are the very ones who would never listen to them in the first place.
I have no vested interest in any technology’s success or failure, and I’m certainly not pandering to an audience. Hell, if I wanted to cultivate a large following, the last thing I’d be spending time on is writing. I’d start a podcast or YouTube channel, align my content with people’s biases, and go all out, telling them what they want to hear. I’d also use AI to write my content to up my pace. It’s the new definition of “productivity.”
One of the criticisms I get is that I shouldn’t be listened to because I don’t love AI enough, which is a strange perspective. Would you really trust someone who is selling you something, or who is completely head over heels in love with a technology? Are you going to get honest criticism? Of course you wouldn’t. But the whole premise of that argument doesn’t make sense. That’s a lot like saying someone isn’t religious enough because they don’t have enough religious bumper stickers on their car.
Framing The Conversation
Much of the debate around future AI advancement revolves around two questions after a claim is made:
What specific technology is being discussed?
When will it arrive?
So much confusion is caused by not clarifying the two follow-up questions. Many throw out the term “AI” as a catch-all, referring to any technology, present or future. For example, the claim that AI will cure cancer. Okay, but what specific AI technology? Is it technology we have today? Some future technology that hasn’t been invented yet? And of course, most importantly, when will this happen? The precision matters.
When asking people to provide some precision regarding their claims, it’s not uncommon to find that people aren’t talking about AI at all. They are talking about magic. For others, they are purely saying “something” will happen at “some point.” Which is basically saying nothing. Back in January of 2024, I published a framework for making sense of human AI predictions, which goes into a bit more detail on this topic.
I do believe that many of the claims made by proponents will be realized at some point through future technological advancements, some even with the technology we have today. I’m certainly hopeful about cures for debilitating illnesses, and a lot of work has already been done. I don’t think we are miles away from seeing those results. This is an example of something I’m hopeful for. Call me an optimist??? However, I don’t know what technology, under what circumstances, or when.
I’m sure so many people thought it was inevitable that by 2015, we’d have hoverboards in common use after watching Back To The Future 2. Our perspective on technological advancement is often skewed and off by a wide margin. It’s always good to keep this in mind.
LLMs
I certainly don’t hate LLMs. I find LLMs useful for various tasks, mostly coding tasks, basic research, and troubleshooting. I occasionally will use them to generate some AI slop images for a blog post or conference presentation. Pinning down my exact usage is a bit hard, since LLMs aren’t my first port of call for every problem. After all, I value my critical thinking skills, skills that people these days seem content to discard.
I never use LLMs for common cognitive tasks and never have an LLM decide for me or write anything on my behalf. I also never have an LLM summarize something I’m trying to understand, because knowledge and understanding aren’t generated from bullet points. The friction is the point in so many tasks where we look to reduce it.
The hype with LLMs hasn’t been commensurate with the realities on the ground. LLMs certainly have their uses. Just like me, people are finding them valuable for a variety of tasks. In my own industry (cybersecurity), there are positive examples in offensive security, vulnerability identification, and assisting analysts in security operations centers. You can also tune LLMs more effectively for specific tasks, which will have a positive effect. However, there are limiting factors to LLMs.
The first is the cost of failure for the use case. LLMs have relatively high failure rates, and when connected in agentic systems, these failures can cascade through the system. Failures compound like interest, to use the words of Demis Hassabis. I mean, the thought of ChatGPT running air traffic control is terrifying.
Second, they are highly manipulable. This is why everyone from startups to hyperscalers has had their AI-based applications hacked. This fundamental manipulability is baked into how LLMs operate. It’s why we have things like prompt injection, and adding LLMs to applications increases their attack surface. This condition is why I’ve described AI Security as a misnomer in the age of generative AI. You aren’t defending the AI. You are defending the application or use case against the effects of adding AI. This is a different problem.
These two factors can be misleading, though. We don’t need AGI-level capabilities for LLMs to be useful or to replace people in their jobs. The moment an LLM-based system is mediocre enough to replace someone, companies will rush to replace people. This is especially true if the cost of failure is lower for a particular job. Although reports of recent layoffs are nothing but AI washing, we are getting a glimpse of what will happen once capabilities arrive.
My biggest concern with LLMs isn’t what they can do for people, it’s what they do to people. I believe we are vastly underestimating the negative cognitive impacts these tools are having and will have on people in the future.
My biggest concern with LLMs isn’t what they can do for people, it’s what they do to people.
AGI
I do believe that AGI is possible, but I don’t think that today’s LLMs will be what gets us there. When do I believe AGI will arrive? 15 to 20 years. Put my precision on this at about 70%. I put the likelihood of LLMs alone becoming AGI at about 15%. But keep in mind, these are mostly guesses guided by intuition and actualities. Caveat: I’m not involved in developing AGI, and the world is a complex place that defies predictions. However, I do believe some factors will confound advancements for a while.
First, I don’t feel LLMs will lead to AGI, and this is where all of the focus seems to be at the moment. Second, I think there is a massive AI investment bubble. The amount of money being invested is nowhere near the value created. This bubble will pop at some point, hopefully not spectacularly. Companies like OpenAI will very likely go out of business. They are hemorrhaging money, and their shares are becoming almost impossible to unload on the secondary market. I mean, they put out a statement about focusing on business, and then just bought a podcast. Not exactly a shining indicator of future success.
I bring this up because this crash will cause some reluctance to invest in the future. Maybe it won’t quite be an AI winter, but it will be an AI fall with colder weather and a lot fewer leaves on the trees. This may stall the advancement toward AGI.
I think some people think that LLMs will go away after the investment bubble pops, but this is nothing but wishful thinking on their part. LLMs are genuinely useful for certain tasks and will continue to be. Also, LLMs are so essential to some people’s identity now, you’ll have to pry them from their cold, dead hands.
When it arrives, I do believe AGI will have vulnerabilities, even if they are not immediately apparent. This would be especially true if AGI were built on today’s LLMs or if it weren’t a single large system but a network of systems. Once deployed, we’d be stuck with these vulnerabilities. This is a perspective I’ve shared publicly for years in my talks and keynotes. There may be something about generalizing to the world that contains inherent vulnerabilities. I have a draft post on this topic that I’ll publish in the future. Unfortunately, I have dozens of posts in draft and only so much time.
ASI and The Intelligence Explosion
Strangely, we haven’t even achieved AGI yet, but labs are already bragging about how we are close to artificial superintelligence (ASI). Okay, it’s not strange, that’s just how hype works. We seem to forget that ASI is a speculative technology, and speculative technology leads to speculative bullshit.
To sum it up, despite believing that AGI is possible, I’m not so sure about ASI. Or at least ASI as it’s traditionally been discussed. I’m not quite sure I can put my finger on exactly why. It’s more of an intuition I have rather than any one specific thing. Of course, I may be the one now talking nonsense.
I think my hesitancy stems from conceptions of ASI, the resources required, and the plateaus that would be encountered. We are told we get there by just packing in “more” and “better”, whatever the more and better happen to be, and this cycle will continue forever. But I don’t think we’ll scale our way there, and we still have to contend with the laws of physics and resource constraints. This is why Ray Kurzweil thinks we need to pave over the universe to create computronium.
I do believe that some recursive self-improvement is possible, but only to a point. Maybe we’ll get to something like an AGI+ but not ASI as it’s traditionally been discussed, with its planet-eating power requirements and its continual recursive self-improvement. However, there is one thing I can say for sure: something will be labeled ASI long before it’s possible. Maybe someone will buy a podcast to promote that perspective! Who knows.
Since I’m unsure if ASI, as it’s been defined, is even possible, I’ll put the odds of reaching ASI in the next 50 years at 10%. But feel free to chalk this up to me saying, “I don’t know,” and disregard everything I’ve said.
What Happens Next
I’ve left no doubt about my pessimism about what happens next and how it’s not good for humanity. Much of the content on this site focuses on that topic. And, no, I don’t think a super-capable AI will see humans as a nuisance and eliminate us. Sorry, Eliezer Yudkowsky, but our manifested problems will be much more mundane.
It’s we, humans, who plant the seeds of our own downfall. When massive unemployment occurs (which may happen well before reaching AGI), there will be no recourse. The so-called abundance movement won’t deliver the value it promises. Many will fall into the “sucks to be you” gap that I’ve defined previously. A segment of the population will remain pinned there, possibly for a generation. This is purely due to incentives and the reluctance or inability to do anything about it. I’ll have more to say on this in the future.
Also, people continue to cede their critical thinking skills to AI. By far my biggest concern is the collapse of culture amid homogenized AI outputs and people’s inability to think independently. I see people more concerned with collecting data than with understanding it. The idea that someone becomes wiser by collecting more data or by engineering a better retrieval system is nonsense. If you need an AI to tell you what you think or believe, you’ve made a fundamental error.
In a previous post, I mentioned the story of Calvisius Sabinus, who, in an attempt to appear learned, devised a shortcut. It didn’t work out so well for him, and this new strategy won’t for us. I have much more to say on this topic as well. But that’s all for now.
Talk to any tech bro, and they’ll be happy to tell you, scarcity is about to become a thing of the past. Abundance is coming and we are going to have so much awesomeness that we can’t even fathom how amazing it will be. Sam Altman recently said that society has been structured around managing scarcity, and now we need to get used to managing abundance. Hell yeah, bro! There’s just one problem. Well… there are many problems, but a big one that isn’t talked about is that nothing in abundance is worth anything. This fact alone can bring visions of utopian abundance crashing down like a house of cards in a tornado, and it’s a lesson we can learn from Napster. Yes, that Napster.
AI, Abundance, and the Future
We are told that scarcity is about to be in our rearview and the bright shiny utopia is out the windshield. With AI and robots doing all of the work, the cost of goods and services will crash to near zero. It’s yachts and Lambos for everyone! Oh, there’s just the small problem that nobody has a job. Damn, there goes my Lambo.
These takes are common, and you see them every day. For example, here’s a random one I saw this morning.
But this isn’t the only claim. They also claim it will cure all diseases and won’t just end poverty, but make everyone rich.
The “things will be free” argument is typically packed among heaps of bullshit, as seen in these examples. It’s intended to overwhelm your critical thinking skills. Let’s just acknowledge that none of this makes sense.
They state that people are going to lose their jobs, but don’t worry, because AI is going to make everything super awesome! They also claim that in this new environment, people are going to become obscenely rich by giving you free shit. Admittedly, I don’t have an MBA, but that doesn’t seem to be how business works.
I’ve covered this topic before in Techno-Communism and the Things Will Cost Nothing Fallacy. In that article, I attacked some of the core premises of this fallacy. I even covered the fact that, despite the premise, things will still cost something, and that nobody is investing in companies to produce zero-dollar goods and services. I may only lightly recover some of that ground, so please refer to the previous article for the core arguments.
This is an important topic to consider now because we will see better AI technologies. We will eventually get to AGI. Many of the nonsense claims people make about today’s LLMs will be true of this new technology, and the impacts will be far-reaching. We need to consider how this environment affects us as humans and our culture.
In this article, I focus on value and frame the lesson of Napster as it relates to abundance and the future.
Napster
I have to do some work here. Let me explain Napster to young millennials and Gen Z, who’ve always had reliable internet connections and never had to wait for anything. Napster was a peer-to-peer file-sharing application that mostly focused on music. If there was a song or album you wanted, you’d search for it and download the MP3s. The songs were encoded at varying quality levels, and depending on how many people had the files and their internet connection speeds, you may have to wait a day or two for the songs or album to download. Oh, and surprise! Sometimes the files you downloaded weren’t what they claimed to be at all.
A look back on the UI of Napster is enough to haunt your dreams.
I use the term “was” in reference to Napster, but apparently, they are still around and drumroll… They’ve pivoted into AI slop. Imagine that! Although you might think this is the lesson of this article, it’s not. It’s just a fun byproduct in the AI era. Enjoy.
Back in 2000, Metallica sued Napster. For clarification, Metallica was a band of aging gentlemen who sounded like Avenged Sevenfold. Sad but true.
At the time, I remembered thinking how backward Metallica looked, like they were just some aging rock band that didn’t understand technology. Most of all, they just looked greedy. People just wanted the freedom to use their music as they wished. Many downloaded MP3s of albums they already owned. For example, maybe you already had Metallica’s black album on tape or found downloading MP3s easier than ripping them from the CD you owned. CDs were also cumbersome, and taking a bunch with you on a road trip was a pain. Sure, people pirated music, but that was a minority. My perspective solidified as the space for digital music grew.
As digital music grew, it came with heavy-handed DRM (Digital Rights Management), which meant that, despite purchasing the music legally, you couldn’t use the music the way you wanted to or play it on devices you chose. Hell, Sony even went so far as to install malware on your computer in an attempt to stop piracy.
Then came streaming, and music essentially became free. The lesson that started with Napster now came full circle with services like Spotify and Apple Music. However, inheriting a gigantic problem.
Music Is Now Free and Worth Nothing
In the ignorance of my youth, I fell victim to a condition most young people do. I failed to see the big picture. When something is free, it is essentially worth nothing. Nobody values music today, and why should they? There was no friction to access it. Nobody had to go to a store and choose between one album and another. Nobody had to wait in line for a midnight release from their favorite artist. Nobody had to choose which albums to take with them on a road trip. Although this sounds like a major inconvenience, it enhanced the value of music for both the listener and the artist. These activities created loyalty and forged a bond.
Musicians were well aware that listeners had a choice when buying music and felt responsible for creating art to the best of their ability. Or at least, this concept was in the back of their mind. Artists also made money selling music, which gave them the freedom to spend more time on their craft, further enhancing their art/product. This environment didn’t require an artist to be as big as Taylor Swift to do so, either.
Purchasing music connected listeners to artists in a way that streaming doesn’t. When people bought an album, they listened to the album the way the artist intended. They could evoke emotion through ebbs and flows, taking people on a musical journey. With streaming, people just add things to playlists and hit shuffle. An artistic vision of an album is completely dismantled, chucked into the chaos of a musical vortex, spinning alongside Snoop Dogg and Conway Twitty.
Now, artists blast out music as fast as they can to increase their breadth because more music means more potential streams. Not releasing music at a steady cadence creates the impression that you’ll be forgotten in the vast sea of content.
Of course, artists now have to make money in other ways, spending less time on their music. They used to agonize over albums and songs, pouring their hearts and souls into them and taking the time to get things right. They also took creative chances. Now, music is collapsing into a formulaic structure where all music sounds the same, and artists bash the formula like the preprogrammed buttons in Mortal Kombat.
Music has become less something to be listened to and more something that provides background noise in daily life. It doesn’t take pride of place as an activity. It’s wallpaper.
Musical Abundance and Lost Value
What we have today is essentially musical abundance. There’s literally so much music on streaming platforms that people can’t find it. In 2024, it was reported that Spotify had over 100 million songs with over 60,000 new songs added per day. Want to guess just how much of that is good music? Certainly less than 1%, there is no way you can convince me that there are 1 million good songs on the platform. In this world of abundance, most things are shit.
As an artist, you basically have to give your music away. As a listener, music is nothing to you. If one song isn’t available, you just listen to something else without emotion. Music, possibly humanity’s very first art form and something that has meant so much to so many humans throughout history, is now stripped of its value and devoid of connection and meaning. In reality, musical abundance hasn’t led to positive outcomes for either the artist or the listener, and this is our lesson here.
In reality, musical abundance hasn’t led to positive outcomes for either the artist or the listener.
The healing effects, the satisfaction, the connection, the memories, and most of the factors that made music valuable and essential to humanity are now gone. Industrialized, homogenized, and mass-produced music has stripped the art of its value. For the far fewer than 1% of songs that aren’t terrible, we are left with momentary blips of completely forgettable, average sounds labeled as music that just happen to hit our ears. No wonder kids are rediscovering the classics.
There’s no going back. Once a technology is implemented, even if it makes things worse, there is no going back. We are stuck with it, which is why it’s so important to understand the trade-offs and implement mitigations before adopting a technology. We just can’t seem to do that.
Now, the music industry also has its share of blame here. It got greedy. A CD never should have cost anywhere near 20 dollars, unless it was a double album or some other special edition. $9.99 was a fair price and should have been the cost for an album. But that time has passed.
Abundance Math Doesn’t Make Sense
Let’s set a couple of foundations for abundance. The premise behind abundance is that companies will employ AI and robots instead of human workers. So, first and foremost, no jobs for most people on the planet.
We are told by futurists and AI bros that abundance will bring a utopia. That everything will be democratized. The cost of everything will be near zero, compute, goods, intelligence, development, and on and on. With so many things driven to essentially zero, not only does the math behind abundance not make sense, but its value as well, as we’ve seen with music.
With so many things driven to essentially zero, not only does the math behind abundance not make sense, but its value as well, as we’ve seen with music.
Let’s start off by addressing the use of the term democratize. Whenever an AI bro uses the term democratize, they actually mean something else: either devalue, degrade, or destroy. I call these the 3 D’s, and I’ve covered this before. But let’s get back to cost and value.
It doesn’t matter if the cost of things is driven to near zero. If they cost something and you have nothing, you still can’t afford it. If a brand new car costs a dollar and you don’t have a dollar, its inexpensiveness doesn’t change the fact that you have to walk. Assistance programs like UBI will hardly have us living lives of luxury.
When people have little to no money, they tend to focus on pure necessities. Pretty much the entire global economy is focused on selling us stuff that we want, not necessarily things we need. That means in this situation of supposed abundance, most companies on the planet disappear.
This shift will rewire our values. I’ve discussed how this may happen in retail through the implementation of agentic shopping. This rewiring isn’t lost on people who are thinking about these issues. The CEO of Walmart resigned because of AI’s potential to upend retail. If successful, more rewiring is on the way and will upend the entire fabric of the modern world. Just imagine, instead of lusting after material things, the dominant belief in the world was meditation and inner peace. Not great for business.
In a world of abundance, many large companies probably won’t exist. Diversification and competition will eat them alive. The abundance of tools and techniques will allow for quick imitation. Sure, some will remain, kind of like the company store in a mining town, but the economic landscape will look vastly different.
We are told that, despite things being so cheap, companies will make money from volume. But once again, with distribution spread across many small companies, it’s hard to see how that amounts to anything more than table scraps. This begs the question, then, where will the money for UBI come from? Even worse, instead of UBI, we may end up with company vouchers, forcing us to buy from a single company or to obtain vouchers for things we don’t need.
Abundance Equals Sameness
Henry Ford is quoted as saying of the Model T that a customer can have any color they want, as long as it’s black. There’s a lesson here for technological abundance. Many are laboring under the delusion that a world of abundance looks like the world of today, just with more. But the reality is this world will look totally different.
The world of technological abundance laid out before us isn’t a world of diverse beauty with green grass and open skies where people spend their days writing poetry and contemplating their existence in the universe. It’s a homogenized world of sameness where everything collapses into uniformity because this uniformity is predictable and can be mass-produced at scale. Individuality and one-offs are unpredictable and costly, and thus must be crushed. It’s a world where humans become little more than a burden.
Sure, people will try to control for this uniformity in the ways that they can. For example, if a family has a 3D printer at home, they have some control over what they print. However, they still need the resources to buy the printer and printing materials, and most would rely on the available designs. This concept of a utopia is starting to smell pretty rank.
New Business? Maybe.
I’m sure it will be said that I’m not envisioning the new businesses that will sprout up and how humans will change their behavior. Sure, the world is a complex place that defies prediction. I acknowledge that adaptation is possible, and surely, humans will change their behavior. They won’t have a choice. But it isn’t going to turn out the way people think.
Just shooting from the hip here, but a world in which people don’t have money and things are essentially free doesn’t seem like a robust environment for business. You won’t see a plethora of new startups all angling for that gigantic pot of nonexistent money.
You won’t see a plethora of new startups all angling for that pot of nonexistent money.
People invest in companies on the hopes of a big return. They take chances and are willing to take losses, but the gambler loses big in this new environment. Because even an investor with money and a successful business bet basically converts that investment into less money. In this environment, there are no incentives to improve, and everything will plateau at mediocrity to preserve existing margins.
Another thing to consider is that this environment is inherently fragile. Any problem, no matter how small, could cause a company to lose money since the margins would be so tight. Any amount of downtime, errors, or integrity issues, whether accidental or intentional, could be catastrophic. The predictable answer from the AI bro is: “But the AI won’t make mistakes.” To which I say, good luck with that.
Now, is it possible for us to evolve beyond money or capital toward a society that aligns its value with other meaningful activities and goals? Sure, it’s possible. But, once again, this wouldn’t be good for the business bros who are pushing this fallacy the hardest. In a world where abundance is truly successful and is beneficial to humanity, it’s bad for business.
Complexities and Negative Impacts
A full conversation on the negative impacts is outside the scope of this article. However, I have covered some of these before.
I’d argue that these people vastly underestimate the world’s complexities and the sheer number of negative impacts this change brings, not just on the economics but on humanity as a whole. There are basically only one or two ways this can kind of go right, and an incalculable number of ways it can go wrong. For example, this is an environment tailor-made for surveillance and totalitarianism. How can it not when your existence is completely dependent on external factors like the state or the generosity of a benefactor?
If you think that people will tolerate a few trillionaires while the world suffers mass unemployment, you are dead wrong. This is so obvious it shouldn’t need to be stated. I can completely envision a group calling themselves The Children of Ludd wreaking havoc. Only their anger won’t be isolated to the machines in data centers and their embodiments out in the world. They’ll direct their anger at the people they see exploiting the situation as well. It won’t be pretty.
I can completely envision a group calling themselves The Children of Ludd wreaking havoc.
In many cases, this new environment will make people far more tribal and extreme and willing to believe just about anything, but this is a topic for another day.
Conclusion
The vision of abundance defined by the tech bros is an absolute fallacy. It’s a world in which AI is talked about more like magic and less like an actual technology. From this tap spouts outlandish claims with no foundation in reality. As we’ve seen, even when abundance works, it has a degradation effect.
A world of successful abundance appears to be bad for business, which raises the question: Why are so many business leaders pushing this concept? If I had to guess, it’s that they hope to make their money before this big crash and leave humanity to pick up the pieces.
Recently, Google, along with Shopify, Etsy, Wayfair, and Target, created Universal Commerce Protocol. A protocol that retailers can use in their AI agents to support product discovery, purchasing, and even support. However, I don’t think retailers understand the full impacts of agentic shopping. When viewed through the autonomous lens, this approach presents the act of shopping as friction, then removes it. Removing the shopping experience from the purchase of products will have the opposite economic effect than retailers hope for.
Companies are betting big that people will want agents to buy things on their behalf. But if this takes off, it could backfire, rewiring the shopping impulse in people’s brains and causing them to buy even less. I don’t think agentic shopping will take off because, once again, innovation is competing with culture. However, this requires a closer look.
Innovation Failures
One of the big reasons innovations fail has nothing to do with a technology’s capabilities and everything to do with the individuals building it not understanding people and culture. A perfect example of this is the vacation agent.
I’ve made fun of the vacation agent before. A nonsensical idea that could only be dreamed up by someone locked away in a room, having no idea what a vacation is. The big point is that the planning is part of the vacation. People don’t view researching activities for a vacation as a burden. It’s part of the fun.
These proposed innovations conflict with culture, which is why I predict that OpenAI’s device will fail. Introducing a device without a screen in a screen-based culture. Here again, we have people thinking it will be different. Sure, innovations come along that break the culture, but they have to be overwhelmingly compelling.
Now, the wonderful folks of Silicon Valley are here to give us agentic shopping, something that nobody actually wants. Every step of the way, proving yet again that they not only don’t understand humans but also don’t understand existing technology.
Shopping Technology
Let’s start with technology. We already have technology today that allows people to check prices to get the best deals. Whether it be flights, hotels, or products. In the US, you are bombarded with Trivago commercials while watching television. Browsers also save address and payment details, and you have options like Apple Pay to make the checkout process even more painless. The friction that’s left is much of what people find enjoyable and what retailers find necessary. (More on this shortly.)
It’s true that people today are using AI as a research tool on products, or at least there is no reason to think they aren’t. After all, they are using AI to self-diagnose their medical conditions. So, there’s no reason to think they aren’t also using it to research the products they may purchase. Companies view the purchase as purely the last step, connecting the dots, if you will. But there’s a big difference between connecting the final dots when a human is doing research and making decisions, and when an autonomous shopping agent does so.
Shopping
The joys of shopping come from outside the technical workflow. Simply put, shopping is fun for people, and our economy depends on that. But what people fail to realize is that shopping with autonomous agents isn’t shopping at all. You’ve amputated the impulse and transformed a fun experience into a purely utilitarian one by viewing shopping as friction. However, even though shopping seems simple, there are complexities that confound the autonomous shopping experience. Let’s start with price.
Shopping with autonomous agents isn’t shopping at all.
Is buying the cheapest thing really the best? Price is purely a number, easy to sort and prioritize. However, thinking that product selection is a matter of price is fooling yourself. What if you don’t get the cheapest thing for a month? What if the company has a bad habit of poorly packaging products? What if the company has poor support? The follow-up questions are endless. It’s true, you could try to account for these countless variables based on personal preference in the agent, but at some point, it becomes too tedious and varies from product to product.
In some cases, even when shopping for the same product, you might prefer the markings, such as the wood grain pattern, on one product over another, even though they are identical. The list here can be endless, and this choice is only for selecting between different options from the same vendor.
Often, you aren’t comparing apples to apples but apples to oranges, and you’re trying to decide between them. Similar products from different vendors or even different formats. For example, when choosing your next vehicle, you might be deciding between a car and a truck. Both vehicles are apples and oranges. In many cases, you might not be able to explain exactly why you made the choice you did.
Nobody likes dealing with salespeople at car dealerships, but browsing different interiors and options is actually fun. But don’t take my word for it, take our entire economy as proof. Advertisements are purely the bait. The hook comes when the browsing starts.
When purchasing services, it becomes even more complex. “Book the cheapest plumber for Tuesday” isn’t a prompting for success. However, let’s keep the conversation on products.
There is still tedium in the shopping process, and edge cases may emerge. For example, I think the idealized view of agentic shopping is something like this:
“Put together five dinners for the week based on my preferences and order all of the ingredients. Have them delivered on Monday.”
I can see where some would find this attractive. Grocery shopping is a far more utilitarian shopping activity than other forms of shopping. However, I’m far too picky about my ingredients, and I’d never trust a stranger to choose an apple or an onion for me. Actually, I’m far too picky about everything, so the question is: are picky consumers the norm or the outlier? Maybe dinners are the exception, but generalized technology rarely stays confined to specific use cases, and enough edge cases are needed to push it into mainstream use.
Will people use agents to outsource the shopping experience? Maybe. But technology choices like this are all about trade-offs, and none of those trade-offs are being considered, especially by retailers. Let’s talk about those now.
Manipulation and Gaming
The more automation is applied in the shopping experience, the more it opens the door to manipulation and gaming. It won’t be the best product vendors and products resorting to dirty tricks. Just like today, people have manipulated search engine optimization (SEO) to rank higher in search results. It’s never the best content at the top, but the people who used the right words to game the algorithm. At least with search engines, all of the content is visible, and we can tell what’s garbage. With an agent, it’s not only invisible to the user but also costs them money.
It’s never the best content at the top.
Of course, this opens the door to scammers as well, giving them new ways to exploit people. Generative AI is highly manipulable, and it’s extremely unlikely that scammers will not find unique ways to exploit these agents. Scammers are typically one step ahead, and it’s likely that the techniques they use will be exploited by marketers and advertisers.
Negative Economic Impacts
By optimizing the purchasing experience, AI agents remove the friction, in this case, known as shopping. The result could create devastating economic impacts. By removing the joy of shopping and turning purchasing into a utilitarian activity, this could cause people to buy fewer things or focus only on necessities. Our entire economy is based on people buying things they want, not necessarily things they need.
Removing the friction from purchasing may seem productive when viewed purely in terms of optimization, and if the trend picks up, there may be a short-term spike as people test the approach and impulse-buy items. However, this won’t last. The use of agents could rewire the brain’s reward system in a way that’s devastating for businesses.
Agentic shopping also removes a vital metric for tech companies, time on platform. More time on platform means more viewing ads for other products that customers may buy or encountering other products that are more preferable. The point of agentic shopping is to avoid time on platform altogether. Advertisers won’t be happy. They’ll insist that agents be further enshitified adding friction to the shopping process, possibly by adding ads or other interventions.
Adding friction to the shopping experience is actually preferable for companies. There’s a reason your local grocery store decides to rearrange the products periodically. It’s not to optimize the store, it’s to un-optimize it. The additional friction of walking around the store leads to additional purchases.
If the shopping impulse gets rewired in people’s brains, this could lead to devastating economic impacts. If I were someone who hated capitalism and wanted to see it fall, I’d be a huge fan of agentic shopping. It would be ironic if the innovations created to build more capital end up being its downfall. Technology has a powerful impact on humanity and can transform or destroy culture. Just look at Gutenberg, television, radio, the Internet, etc., as examples.
Conclusion
Companies are investing in technology that may cause their demise, driven by the fear of leaving revenue streams on the table. It’s that simple. They don’t want to be left behind. The irony is that the search for additional revenue may lead people to buy less.
Ultimately, I don’t think agentic shopping will take off. The shopping impulse ingrained in our culture is too strong, but if it does, the unintended consequences may have the opposite effect. In an attempt to get people to buy more, by removing the friction, they buy less.
It says much about our current moment that “slop” is Merriam-Webster’s 2025 word of the year. Seems mediocrity is having a moment. In this moment, a delusion has taken hold, centered on AI and the future of work: the AI creativity delusion. For the past couple of years, companies and influencers have told us the world is our slop oyster. If we can imagine it, we can slop it. Ideas and creativity are what matter, and everything else should be automated. We are told that, despite the goal of replacing humans in the workplace, the near-term future of work is humans, still in the loop, doing what they do best, flexing their creativity and letting AI do the rest. Although conceptually sound, this vision falls apart under even the slightest analysis, and it will hit younger generations the hardest.
The AI Creativity Delusion and the Expertise Loophole
Let me address the AI creativity delusion fueling the push for AI-powered coworkers. The premise goes that humans at work will flex their creativity by delegating their AIs to handle other tasks. This way, the human does what they are good at (creativity and ideas), and the AI does what it’s good at (everything else). Many may nod in agreement. However, this premise falls apart under scrutiny. We’ll get to this in a moment, but first, a loophole.
I should note a loophole in AI tool productivity: the expertise loophole. This loophole applies only under specific circumstances, namely when the user already has domain expertise. A user with domain expertise and an understanding of how AI tools fail can provide corrections or put the tool back on track. You need to understand the task, what the correct outputs are, and have enough experience to know when you aren’t getting the right answers.
Expertise also informs when to use AI tools and when not to, because an expert understands what needs to be done and which tasks AI can assist with in delivering the best results. I believe it’s this expertise loophole that blinds people to the real issues we are about to face.
Given the conditions of the expertise loophole, any productivity gains are temporary and apply only to specific job tasks for a limited time. As experienced people leave, less experienced AI-powered coworkers cannot fill the gaps. Mainly because they never have an opportunity to gain experience, the very experience they need to develop creativity in the domain. Secondarily, they outsource the social aspects of their jobs, further isolating themselves from their co-workers. It’s a one-two punch that’s hard to recover from.
A significant flaw in the creativity argument is the misconception that ideas are unique, precious resources that must be protected and fostered. I’ve written about this before, explaining that ideas are common, run-of-the-mill daily occurrences for everyone on the planet. Most ideas are ill-thought-out, half-baked, or just plain stupid. This is our reality.
The Younger Generation as AI-Powered Coworkers
I read an article recently, where a Gen Z founder claims that the younger generation will have an advantage in the workplace because they are growing up fluent in AIand this is helping them stand apart from their older peers. This is the sort of unadulterated, bubble-living bullshit we’ve come to expect these days. Younger generations may be growing up in the flatulence of AI, but that’s something else entirely.
Prolific AI use will ultimately make the younger generation worse off, as they are not set up for success in key areas that align with their value as employees.
I’ll make a claim of my own, and it’s the exact opposite. Prolific AI use will ultimately make the younger generation worse off, as they are not set up for success in key areas that align with their value as employees. This would be true even in a reality where generative AI is near-perfect, and we all know we are far from that.
I’m not attempting to beat up on younger generations. I feel for them, and I want to help. There have been so many ways they haven’t been positioned for success, and now generative AI comes along, putting more nails in the coffin.
These companies want to make you less capable and more dependent.
These companies want to make you less capable and more dependent. If you are dependent, you’ll not only need to use their tools to do your job but also in your day-to-day life. This is not a great option.
Marshall McLuhan said that every augmentation is an amputation. Framing technology in this way opens the door to unforeseen circumstances. In the case of younger generations, the amputation happens before the limb even has a chance to develop. In our case, rather than a physical limb, we are referring to cognitive and social abilities.
When we peer beneath the paint, we find that the very skills needed to make someone valuable at work are precisely those not being developed by overly ambitious AI-powered coworkers. The ones not communicating with their coworkers because their bots attend their meetings and respond to email and text communication.
Revisiting Creativity In Younger Generations
How does someone develop their creativity in the first place without experience? They don’t. Generative AI today can assist people with experience in specific tasks and under certain conditions. It helps with some tasks better than others. This is because someone with experience, especially domain experience, knows how to approach certain solutions, identify the right conditions, and know when the system is malfunctioning. An experienced professional can flex their creativity in this environment. The same cannot be said of the effectiveness of younger generations in the same jobs, despite having access to the same tools. Effectiveness will decline sharply across multiple dimensions.
First, they’ll never develop the social and communication skills necessary to be effective members of an organization. Second, they’ll not gain the experience needed in a given domain. Finally, they’ll never develop the mythical creativity discussed in AI circles due to a lack of expertise and social skills. All of this will be due to the overreliance on generative AI tools.
Let us examine some aspects of AI-powered coworkers. AI-powered coworkers using generative AI tools to attend meetings, take notes, and create action items. They use generative AI tools to communicate with co-workers. Using generative AI tools summarize documentation, books, and countless other sources of knowledge. Using pre-made generative AI tools to perform the job tasks. And the list goes on. This may look productive, but it’s not effective, and that’s a critical difference. There is a subtle deception at work here because AI tools can make people feel more productive and even powerful, even when they are not.
You can’t summarize your way to expertise, you can’t build relationships by outsourcing communication, and you can’t get experience by not doing things. Does this sound like a successful future workforce? Yet this is exactly the vision on offer, and this fuels the AI creativity delusion.
We have a distorted view of creativity, perceiving it as exercised by lone geniuses, but the reality is that most of the creativity needed for success in a business context is exercised in groups through relationships and collaboration. The same relationships and collaboration that aren’t developing in the AI-powered coworker scenario. When people start treating their coworkers like apps, nothing good happens.
The reality is that most of the creativity needed for success in a business context is exercised in groups through relationships and collaboration.
This should all make sense. When has anyone ever admired someone’s creativity when they didn’t actually know anything? It even seems silly to say out loud. To break the rules, you must know where the rules are and what hard constraints exist, and that requires awareness and expertise.
Knowing a tool doesn’t make you an expert; it makes you a tool. But let’s dig a bit deeper with a specific example.
We are told that meeting recording and transcription services free us from taking notes, allowing us to focus on what’s happening. However, this couldn’t be further from the truth. People pay LESS attention when they think a meeting is recorded, especially when they think it’s going to be summarized and bulleted for them. The reality is, taking notes IS paying attention.
When the human brain summarizes, it stores and reinforces. In a learning scenario, when people began taking notes on a computer, they could record everything the teacher said. But, this isn’t the benefit people thought it was. It seems that the act of taking notes with pen and paper forces us to distill what’s being said down to its essence, which is much better for learning and retention. I know it’s hard to believe, but pen and paper are technology too.
Not only that, but if we view this from a social context, there is a courtesy and respect that occurs when people see you taking notes, rather than simply grinning like a dipshit, or when people see you performing background tasks while they are talking. But, oh no. My AI has got this covered.
So you’re going to have a hard time convincing me that people who use LLMs to summarize and respond to their emails and text messages, attend meetings on their behalf, and have no domain experience or developed any workplace social skills are going to have a leg up on the competition.
What’s Old Is New Again
Some things never change. I’ve been on this tools impacting humans beat for quite some time. Back in 2010, I gave a series of talks at security conferences titled “Your Tools Are Killing You.” The premise was that people were completely reliant on their tools and couldn’t perform the task otherwise. If the tool was blind to an issue, the human was likewise blind to it. Newer people to cybersecurity learned the tool, not the task. These conditions ultimately reduced people’s effectiveness at their jobs. Sound familiar? However, the generalized nature of generative AI makes this far worse.
Mediocrity Is The Future Of Work
In September, Harvard Business Review published an article on how AI-generated “workslop” was destroying productivity. In essence, workers using AI tools were passing low-quality content to co-workers, which required them to do more work. This is a sort of productivity shell game where a speedup in one area causes a slowdown in another, pretty far from AGI if you ask me.
When everything is slop, everything is mediocre. We’ve allowed companies to reframe what’s acceptable into mediocrity. We don’t hire employees to give the bare minimums. Nobody responds to a job interview with, “If you hire me, I promise to do just enough.” This is hardly a selling point. When you hire someone to paint your house, you don’t think a mediocre job is acceptable, but if you receive a mediocre report, somehow it’s now fine if it is labeled as “AI-powered.” All the mistakes and inaccuracies are just how things are now.
AIs don’t care about quality; that’s a human’s job. Yet quality is on a steep decline. Some are making low-quality work product acceptable because AI is in the loop. But what happens when people forced to use AI tools in the workplace stop caring about the quality of the work they produce? Nothing good.
Encouraged or forced to use AI for everything, humans will be nothing more than meat-sack automatons providing the embodiment for AI. Most jobs don’t consist of a single task, which is why AIs still need humans in the loop for the current and near future. This vision is hardly motivating or inspirational.
Conclusion
We’ve built our AI temple atop fissures, allowing escaping gases to induce hallucinations, fooling us into thinking we are predicting the future. We remain blinded to the real issues confronting us and their negative impacts. We cling to the AI creativity delusion. Which, ironically, prevents us from using AI tools to their full potential.
Creativity doesn’t come without experience, and most of the creativity needed for success in a business context isn’t the work of lone geniuses, but through collaboration. If we don’t identify and correct these issues soon, we are all but dooming younger generations. We are currently in the f—k around stage, but the find out stage is on the horizon.
The past couple of years have been fueled entirely by vibes. Awash with nonsensical predictions and messianic claims that AI has come to deliver us from our tortured existence. Starting shortly after the launch of ChatGPT, internet prophets have claimed that we are merely six months away from major impacts and accompanying unemployment. GPT-5 was going to be AGI, all jobs would be lost, and nothing for humans to do except sit around and post slop to social media. This nonsense litters the digital landscape, and instead of shaming the litterers, we migrate to a new spot with complete amnesia and let the littering continue.
Pushing back against the hype has been a lonely position for the past few years. Thankfully, it’s not so lonely anymore, as people build resilience to AI hype and bullshit. Still, the damage is already done in many cases, and hypesters continue to hype. It’s also not uncommon for people to be consumed by sunk costs or oblivious to simple solutions. So, the dumpster fire rodeo continues.
Security and Generative AI Excitement
Anyone in the security game for a while knows the old business vs security battle. When security risks conflict with a company’s revenue-generating (or about to be revenue-generating) products, security will almost always lose. Companies will deploy products even with existing security issues if they feel the benefits (like profits) outweigh the risks. Fair enough, this is known to us, but there’s something new now.
What we’ve learned over the past couple of years is that companies will often plunge vulnerable and error-prone software deep into systems without even having a clear use case or a specific problem to solve. This is new because it involves all risk with potentially no reward. These companies are hoping that users define a use case for them, creating solutions in search of problems.
What we’ve learned over the past couple of years is that companies will often plunge vulnerable and error-prone software deep into systems without even having a clear use case or a specific problem to solve.
I’m not referring to the usage of tools like ChatGPT, Claude, or any of the countless other chatbot services here. What I’m referring to is the deep integration of these tools into critical components of the operating system, web browser, or cloud environments. I’m thinking of tools like Microsoft’s Recall, OpenAI’s Operator, Claude Computer Use, Perplexity’s Comet browser, and a host of other similar tools. Of course, this also extends to critical components in software that companies develop and deploy.
At this point, you may be wondering why companies choose to expose themselves and their users to so much risk. The answer is quite simple, because they can. Ultimately, these tools are burnouts for investors. These tools don’t need to solve any specific problem, and their deep integration is used to demonstrate “progress” to investors.
I’ve written before about the point when the capabilities of a technology can’t go wide, it goes deep. Well, this is about as deep as it gets. These tools expose an unprecedented attack surface and often violate security models that are designed to keep systems and users safe. I know what you are thinking, what do you mean, these tools don’t have a use case? You can use them for… and also ah…
The Vacation Agent???
The killer use case that’s been proposed for these systems and parroted over and over is the vacation agent. A use case that could only be devised by an alien from a faraway planet who doesn’t understand the concept of what a vacation is. As the concept goes, these agents will learn about you from your activity and preferences. When it’s time to take a vacation, the agent will automatically find locations you might like, activities you may enjoy, suitable transportation, and appropriate days, and shop for the best deals. Based on this information, it automatically books this vacation for you. Who wouldn’t want that? Well, other than absolutely everyone.
What this alien species misses is the obvious fact that researching locations and activities is part of the fun of a vacation! Vacations are a precious resource for most people, and planning activities is part of the fun of looking forward to a vacation. Even the non-vacation aspect of searching for the cheapest flight is far from a tedious activity, thanks to the numerous online tools dedicated to this task. Most people don’t want to one-shot a vacation when the activity removes value, and the potential for issues increases drastically.
But, I Needed NFTs Too
Despite this lack of obvious use cases, people continue to tell me that I need these deeply integrated tools connected to all my stuff and that they are essential to my future. Well, people also told me I needed NFTs, too. I was told NFTs were the future of art, and I’d better get on board or be left behind, living in the past, enjoying physical art like a loser. But NFTs were never about art, or even value. They were a form of in-group signaling. When I asked NFT collectors what value they got from them, they clearly stated it wasn’t about art. They’d tell me how they used their NFT ownership as an invitation to private parties at conferences and such. So, fair enough, there was some utility there.
In the end, NFTs are safer than AI because they don’t really do anything other than make us look stupid. Generative AI deployed deeply throughout our systems can expose us to far more than ridicule, opening us up to attack, severe privacy violations, and a host of other compromises.
In a way, this public expression of look at me, I use AI for everything has become a new form of in-group signaling, but I don’t think this is the flex they think it is. In a way, these people believe this is an expression of preparation for the future, but it could very well be the opposite. The increase in cognitive offloading and the manufactured dependence is precisely what makes them vulnerable to the future.
In a way, these people believe this is an expression of preparation for the future, but it could very well be the opposite. The increase in cognitive offloading and the manufactured dependence is precisely what makes them vulnerable to the future.
Advice Over Reality
Social media is awash with countless people who continue to dispense advice, telling others that if you don’t deploy wonky, error-prone, and highly manipulable software deeply throughout your business, then they are going to be left behind. Strange advice since the reality is that most organizations aren’t reaping benefits from generative AI.
Here’s something to consider. Many of the people doling out this advice haven’t actually done the thing they are talking about or have any particular insight into the trend or problems to be solved. But it doesn’t end with business advice. This trend also extends to AI standards and recommendations, which are often developed at least in part by individuals with little or no experience in the topic. This results in overcomplicated guidance and recommendations that aren’t applicable in the real world.
The reason a majority of generative AI projects fail is due to several factors. Failing to select an appropriate use case, overlooking complexity and edge cases, disregarding costs, ignoring manipulation risks, holding unrealistic expectations, and a host of other issues are key drivers of project failure. Far too many organizations expect generative AI to act like AGI and allow them to shed human resources, but this isn’t a reality today.
LLMs have their use cases, and these use cases increase if the cost of failure is low. So, the lower the risk, the larger the number of use cases. Pretty logical. Like most technology, the value from generative AI comes from selective use, not blanket use. Not every problem is best solved non-deterministically.
Another thing I find surprising is that a vast majority of generative AI projects are never benchmarked against other approaches. Other approaches may be better suited to the task, more explainable, and far more performant. If I had to take a guess, I would guess that this number is close to 0.
Generative AI and The Dumpster Fire Rodeo
Despite the shift in attitude toward generative AI and the obvious evidence of its limitations, we still have instances of companies forcing their employees to use generative AI due to a preconceived notion of a productivity explosion. Once again, ChatGPT isn’t AGI. This do everything with generative AI approach extends beyond regular users to developers, and it is here that negative impacts increase.
I’ve referred to the current push to make every application generative AI-powered as the Dumpster Fire Rodeo. Companies are rapidly churning out vulnerable AI-powered applications. Relatively rare vulnerabilities, such as remote code execution, are increasingly common. Applications can regularly be talked into taking actions the developer didn’t intend, and users can manipulate their way into elevated privileges and gain access to sensitive data they shouldn’t have access to. Hence, the dumpster fire analogy. Of course, this also extends to the fact that application performance can worsen with the application of generative AI.
The generalized nature of generative AI means that the same system making critical decisions inside of your application is the same one that gives you recipes in the style of Shakespeare. There is a nearly unlimited number of undocumented protocols that an attacker can use to manipulate applications implementing generative AI, and these are often not taken into consideration when building and deploying the application. The dumpster fire continues. Yippee Ki-Yay.
Conclusion
Despite the obvious downsides, the dumpster fire rodeo is far from over. There’s too much money riding on it. The reckless nature with which people deploy generative AI deep into systems continues. Rather than identifying an actual problem and applying generative AI to an appropriate use case, companies choose to marinade everything in it, hoping that a problem emerges. This is far from a winning strategy. Companies should be mindful of the risks and choose the right use cases to ensure success.
Weaved through the fabric of the hustle-bro culture, threaded with the drivel of influencers, lies one of the biggest cons of our current age. This is the false perception that everything we do has to be for some financial gain or public attention. With everything in life revolving around social currency or actual currency, removing friction enables us to reach value quickly. But don’t fret. The slop dealer is here with a plan to deliver us salvation, telling us that ideas are what’s important and everything else is pointless friction, needing to be optimized to reach full potential. Like so many things in our current moment, if only this were true.
Despite the decline in excitement for AI and the potential resulting market corrections, unfortunately, slop is here to stay. Although people outwardly complain about it, they are secretly glad it’s here. Being unique, thoughtful, and creative is hard. Slop allows people to swaddle themselves in a false comfort devoid of any real creativity. So, damn the torpedoes, full slop ahead.
Slop, Enshittification, and Brain Rot
Slop, enshittification, and brain rot are terms burned into our current lexicon. Although each term has a different definition, one referring to outputs, one referring to platforms, and one referring to what it does to us. When I use the generalized term slop here, I mean a mixture of all three together, a sort of thick, rancid mixture reminiscent of manure and White Zinfandel. This is because the combined term aligns better with the content and its overall impact.
The Slop Dealer
The slop dealer tells us everything is a hustle, and we need to get on board to reduce friction everywhere we can to accelerate value or be left in the dust by others using AI. They don’t talk of reasonable AI usage or prescriptions for specific tasks; it’s all or nothing. We need to surrender to the higher power. The slop dealer embodies everything that tech bro culture stands for. It’s the current equivalent of a get-rich-quick scheme, only instead of taking our money, they are stealing our attention and our satisfaction. Although sometimes they take our money too.
The slop dealer swindles us by telling us what we want to hear, that hard things are a thing of the past, and all we need is an idea. After all, everybody has ideas. These are the influencers, wanna-be influencers, and other AI useful idiots vomiting nonsense on social media. They aren’t peddling secret knowledge; they are peddling bullshit.
This pandering is done so we’ll follow them, subscribe to their newsletters, or buy their nonsense. But one of the biggest lies of all is the false impression that the value of creative pursuits lies in the end result.
Most of these people have no shame and not only believe in Dead Internet Theory, but also actively work to make it a reality. If you are wondering why people en masse find tech bro culture abhorrent, look no further than this stunning piece of work.
To quote this guy directly, “How I personally feel? I have no idea. The internet in my mind is already dead. I am the problem, right?” I get the impression this isn’t the first time he’s realized he’s the problem. Unfortunately, acknowledgement of this isn’t enough to change behavior.
The Slop Architect
The slop architect works not in traditional mediums but in ideas. To the slop architect, execution, skills, and experience are secondary, bowing at the pedestal of ideas. The fact is, most ideas are ill-thought-out, half-baked, or just plain fucking stupid. The slop architect doesn’t care because they don’t carry ideas to term; they birth them instantly, shoving them out into the world to fend for themselves as they move on to something else. I mean, the vape Tamagotchi was someone’s idea, too. Yes, please! Let’s accelerate these!
Ideas aren’t unique, precious resources, but common, run-of-the-mill, everyday occurrences for everyone on the planet. The slop architecture amplifies the fallacy that ideas are sacred and pushes the idea that if more ideas were executed, the world would be a better place. If only we had more apps, more books, more music, and the list goes on and on. This connects with people because everyone has ideas.
What most people who have thought about it for more than two seconds realize is that we don’t get to the value of an idea purely by having it. Ideas in isolation are senseless ramblings of the brain. Ideas forged and refined in the fire of execution, experience, and reflection are invaluable and fulfilling. Our ideas are never challenged in the slop architecture, leading us to new discoveries and paths, but are chucked out into the world and quickly discarded, like forgotten attempts at memes that nobody finds funny.
The AI Slop Architecture
The slop architect’s vision is implemented with the slop architecture, which presents itself as a process or application. The slop architecture is pitched as the way forward, the next-generation architecture fueling the future of humanity’s pursuits. But a simple scratch of the surface paint is all it takes to expose the entire thing as an empty shell.
When you see people pitching these types of things, it uncovers people who don’t understand creativity and certainly don’t understand where value exists in a process. Everything is a hustle for the sake of hustling. This person is hardly the only one.
Back in 2023, I jokingly created my own version of the slop architecture, which I referred to as IPIP, long before the AI influencers made it a reality.
This article was complete with a description of what would come to be known as vibe coding. “The hype has led to a new form of software development that appears to be more like casting a spell than developing software.”
Taking the slop architecture to heart, it’s not hard to find implementations already running. Books, slides, music, applications, nothing is off limits. Everything is fair game in the slop era.
Ah, Magic bookifier. Yeah, let me get on that. Any time someone puts magic in reference to AI, it’s bullshit.
People also fantasize about what advanced AI is or will be able to do. Take this use case for AGI, for example.
It reminds me of the Luke Skywalker meme where he’s handed the most powerful weapon in the galaxy and immediately points it at his face. This is informative for a couple of reasons. Movies can’t be exactly like the books for reasons other than length. They are different media with different tools. But look at the response. Human work isn’t worth protecting in the future. This is a far more common perspective than many think.
Even apps. It’s slop from all angles. So, if these tools already exist, why aren’t we all kicking back, receiving our profits? Maybe there’s something more to this than having an idea.
But we can’t just have a couple of people successfully making apps. It needs to be bigger! We are now told to await the arrival of the first billion-dollar solopreneur. Hark! The herald angels sing. Glory to the slop-born king! However, we shouldn’t get our hopes up. Setting aside how highly unlikely this is, people also win the lottery, so unless we have a mass of billion-dollar solopreneurs, it’s not proof of much. However, whenever people have strongly held beliefs, they will always point to exceptions as the rule.
It’s far more common for people to talk about a single person making a million-dollar app, and that we all can make them now. Even if this were true, it’s not like billions of people are going to make million-dollar apps or profit from a trillion new books. No degree in economics is necessary to see that the numbers don’t work. Besides, if billions of people can and will do something, then the whole enterprise becomes devalued.
The slop architecture deprives us of so much, sucking the soul out of activities until only the shriveled husk remains. There’s no learning with the slop architecture. No growth. No Reflection. No Satisfaction. It even robs us of a sense of style, something so foundational to the satisfaction of human artistic pursuits. But all things require sacrifice on the pyre of optimization. In the end, the slop architecture doesn’t democratize. It devalues, degrades, and destroys.
In the end, the slop architecture doesn’t democratize. It devalues, degrades, and destroys.
The Friction Is The Point
I’m going to let my friends in tech in on a secret, which isn’t a secret at all. The friction of an activity is directly related to the value you receive from it. The mistake being made is comparing an activity’s friction to the load time of an application or streamlining a user interface. I’ve written previously about how the next generation could be known as The Slop Generation and how we continue to devalue art. However, the removal of friction creates harmful follow-on effects.
Imagine telling Alex Honnold, “Dude, you don’t need to free solo El Capitan. We have a helicopter that can drop you off at the top.” People may see this example as silly because Alex obviously climbs mountains for reasons other than getting to the top, but it’s a mistake to assume other pursuits don’t contain similar value purely because they aren’t mountain climbing. Deep experiences don’t result from things that provide instant gratification or have little friction. Nobody finds meaning in a prompt or the resulting generation.
Deep experiences don’t result from things that provide instant gratification or have little friction.
People may see this example as silly because climbing a mountain without ropes is obviously different from something like writing a song. Except it’s not when viewed through the lens of experience. Alex Honnold doesn’t free solo mountains to get to the top or because ropes and safety equipment are too expensive; he does it because he knows there is value in the friction of his experience. He’s both challenging himself and learning about himself at the same time. He’s having an actual experience, which is hard to describe to people who have never had one. This experience enriches the conclusion of the activity, the accomplishment, which coincidentally happens to be getting to the top. However, when pursuits are framed in terms of the end results, it appears that reaching the top is the goal, and the removal of friction is logical.
Most people will never free solo a mountain, compete in the Olympics, or achieve any of the other remarkable feats that athletes at the top of their game accomplish, but that doesn’t mean we can’t have similar and fulfilling experiences, and we do this through exploration and conquering friction. When you are operating at the top of your game, you realize you aren’t competing with others, but yourself.
An artist puts a piece of themselves inside every work of art they create. AI deprives artists of having a piece of themselves included in the art, making the generated output purely an artifact of running a tool.
Slop Is Here To Stay
Immediately after Ozzy Osborne died, Oz Slop invaded social media. The prince of darkness himself fell victim to people’s boredom and lack of creativity. People chose to pay tribute to him, not through stories and anecdotes, but by slopping him into manufactured content. I can’t think of a more insulting way to pay tribute to an artist, but this is our future. Slop instead of something to say. Slop instead of stories and memories. Slop instead of emotion. Slop as a coping mechanism. May the slop be with you.
A disheartening thought is that no matter what happens to the market for generative AI, the slop will remain. People post this slop not because they enjoy it, but purely because it gives them something to post. Slop content is a stand-in for having something to say. It’s easy to generate and requires little thought, the perfect complement to today’s reactionary and performative social media environments.
In a way, this trend could create a new line of demarcation, where we start referring to things as “Before Slop” and “After Slop” to identify the creative expressions that preceded and followed the arrival of AI-generated content.
Conclusion
In the end, the slop architecture doesn’t generate experiences. Nobody is going to be on their deathbed mulling over their favorite prompts or sit down with friends and reminisce about the time they poked at a generative AI system for hours trying to get it to generate a particular image. The slop architecture doesn’t create a legacy or generate stories worth remembering or worth sharing, just pieces of forgotten garbage littering the digital landscape.